Smart With Math, Dumb With Money? Blame Behavioural Biases

In short:

• Traditional finance assumes we make rational money decisions, but behavioral finance reveals we're beautifully irrational creatures driven by emotions and biases 

• Four major biases sabotage our finances: loss aversion (hating losses more than loving gains), present bias (choosing instant gratification), herd mentality (following the crowd), and overconfidence (thinking we're financial geniuses) 

• These biases manifest in everyday behaviors like holding losing stocks, accumulating credit card debt, chasing trending investments, and panic-selling during market downturns 

• Simple strategies can outsmart our biased brains: automating decisions, setting rules in advance, delaying purchases, tracking spending, and finding accountability partners 

  

"The enemy is us," said the great investor Warren Buffett, though he was talking about our tendency to be our own worst financial advisors. If you've ever wondered why you bought that expensive gadget you barely use, or why you sold your mutual funds right when the market crashed, welcome to the fascinating world of behavioural finance.

What Is Behavioural Finance?

For decades, traditional finance operated under a charming delusion: that humans are rational beings who make perfectly logical money decisions. Picture a world where everyone carefully weighs pros and cons, calculates expected returns, and never lets emotions cloud their judgment. Sounds lovely, doesn't it? Also sounds nothing like the real world.

Behavioural finance is where psychology meets money, acknowledging the uncomfortable truth that we're emotional, irrational, and wonderfully human in our financial decisions. This field gained serious academic credibility thanks to brilliant minds like Daniel Kahneman, who won a Nobel Prize for showing how our mental shortcuts (called heuristics) often lead us astray, and Richard Thaler, who demonstrated that small "nudges" can dramatically improve our financial behaviour.

As Kahneman put it in his masterpiece "Thinking, Fast and Slow," we have two systems of thinking: one that's fast and intuitive, another that's slow and deliberate. Unfortunately, when it comes to money, our fast system often takes the wheel – and it's not always headed in the right direction.

Common Biases and How They Affect You

Let's meet the usual suspects that regularly pickpocket our financial future:

Loss Aversion: The Pain of Losing

Here's a quirky fact about human nature: losing ₹1,000 feels roughly twice as painful as winning ₹1,000 feels good. This isn't just being dramatic – it's hardwired into our brains.

Meet Rajesh, a software engineer from Bangalore. He bought Paytm shares at ₹1,500, watched them tumble to ₹500, and still holds them today. "They'll come back," he insists, while his portfolio bleeds. Meanwhile, he sold his Infosys shares for a small profit, missing out on significant gains. Classic loss aversion: we hold losers too long and sell winners too early.

Present Bias: Tomorrow Can Wait

"I'll start saving for retirement next year," says Priya, a 28-year-old marketing executive, as she books another weekend getaway. Next year arrives, and the refrain continues. Our brains are terrible at valuing future rewards compared to immediate pleasures.

This isn't about being lazy or irresponsible. Our ancestors needed to focus on immediate survival – finding food today mattered more than planning for next winter. Unfortunately, this wiring doesn't serve us well in an era where we need to save for decades-long retirements.

Herd Mentality: Following the Crowd

Remember the cryptocurrency frenzy of 2021? Suddenly, everyone from your barber to your neighbour's teenager was a crypto expert. "Bitcoin is the future!" they declared, right before buying at peak prices.

Humans are social creatures. When everyone seems to be making money from something, our fear of missing out (FOMO) kicks in. We assume the crowd knows something we don't. Sometimes they do. Often, they're just as clueless as we are, creating bubbles that inevitably burst.

Overconfidence: The Illusion of Expertise

Studies show that 80% of drivers believe they're above average. Similarly, many investors think they can beat the market through stock picking, despite evidence that even professional fund managers struggle to do so consistently.

Take Suresh, who spent his weekends researching penny stocks and bragging about his "winners" at office parties. He conveniently forgot to mention the losers, which outnumbered his successes three to one. Overconfidence is expensive – it leads to excessive trading, inadequate diversification, and taking on too much risk.

How These Biases Show Up in Real Life

Let's follow Meera, a composite character representing millions of Indians, through her financial journey. Despite earning well as a consultant, she carries credit card debt because paying the minimum feels manageable (present bias). She hasn't started a SIP because retirement seems too distant to worry about (also present bias).

When the market crashed in March 2020, she panicked and moved her investments to fixed deposits, locking in losses (loss aversion and herd mentality). Later, when everyone was talking about direct equity investments, she jumped in without proper research (overconfidence and herd mentality again).

Sound familiar? These biases don't operate in isolation – they team up to create a perfect storm of poor financial decisions.

What You Can Do About It

The good news? Once you recognize these biases, you can build systems to work around them:

Automate Your Decisions: Set up automatic SIPs and savings transfers. When the decision is out of your hands, biases can't interfere. As they say, "Pay yourself first" – but make it automatic so you don't have to rely on willpower.

Set Rules in Advance: Decide on your asset allocation when markets are calm, not during volatility. Write down your investment rules and stick to them. As Benjamin Graham advised, "The investor's chief problem – and even his worst enemy – is likely to be himself."

Delay Major Purchases: Institute a 24-hour rule for non-essential purchases above ₹5,000. Often, the urge passes, and you realize you didn't really need that item.

Track Your Spending: Awareness is powerful. When you see where your money actually goes, you naturally make better choices. Use apps, spreadsheets, or whatever works for you.

Find an Accountability Buddy: Share your financial goals with a trusted friend or family member. Social pressure can be a powerful force for good when channeled properly.

---

Remember, the goal isn't to become a perfectly rational financial robot – that's impossible and probably not much fun. The goal is to recognize when your brain might be leading you astray and have systems in place to gently guide you back on track.

After all, as Charlie Munger wisely noted, "It is remarkable how much long-term advantage people like us have gotten by trying to be consistently not stupid, instead of trying to be very intelligent." In the world of personal finance, not being stupid often beats being brilliant.